We have been made aware of emails falsely claiming to originate from our firm sent from email addresses which are not from our firm’s domain name. Please note that these emails were not sent by us and may be part of a phishing or fraud attempt.

If you receive an email that appears suspicious or claims to be from our firm (but not sent using our firm’s official domain – @chooi.com.my), do not act on it. Instead, contact us directly at our official email address (contact@chooi.com.my) to verify its authenticity.

CIPAA adjudication – turning into a rigid tool?

November 2026

By Janet Chai Pei Ying

In a 2024 Federal Court decision in the case of Anas Construction Sdn Bhd v JKP Sdn Bhd and another appeal [2024] 2 MLJ 543, the Federal Court by way of a majority decided that as the adjudicator’s jurisdiction was limited to matters referred to the adjudicator under sections 5 and 6 of the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (“CIPAA”) meant that the claimant must identify the cause of action and the provision under the contract that supported the cause of action. That as the cause of action in this case based on clause 36.6 of the contract was not relied upon or expressly pleaded in the payment claim, the adjudicator had exceeded his jurisdiction in deciding the dispute based on clause 36.6 of the contract. Further, the non-giving of the opportunity by the adjudicator for the parties to submit or canvass the cause of action under clause 36.6 of the contract before making the decision was a denial of natural justice.

The dissenting judgment on the other hand held that non-citing or even the citing of a wrong clause or provision of a construction contract did not and could not render the adjudication bereft of jurisdiction, given the following facts:-

  1. The subject of the claim and the cause of action was always about the single dispute over the claim for professional fees.
  2. The respondent was not in the least confused and being fully aware of the thrust of the appellant’s claim put up a meaningful response.
  3. Clause 36.6 of the contract was in fact drawn to the adjudicator’s attention by the respondent itself.
  4. Adjudication proceedings involved inquisitorial inquiries and there was no procedural unfairness when he did not invite the parties to comment on clause 36.6 of the contract.

The dissenting judgment went on to point out that so long as the adjudicator confined himself to the dispute that was referred to him under section 5 of CIPAA, even if he decided it wrongly, he had not exceeded his jurisdiction and there was no breach of natural justice.

The consequence of the Federal Court’s decision in Anas Construction is that it is now possible to challenge the jurisdiction of an adjudicator, if the specific provision of the contract upon which the cause of action was based has not been expressly stated in the payment claim.

Subsequent to this Federal Court decision, we have seen parties challenging adjudication decision based on the Federal Court’s decision in Anas Construction. Whilst challenges thus far before the High Court in the cases of Lien Dak Construction Co Sdn Bhd v SCMM Bina Sdn Bhd [2026] MLJU 3076 and Mori Park Sdn Bhd v Jack-In Pile (M) Sdn Bhd and other cases [2026] MLJU 2620 did not make headway, it remains to be seen whether these decisions will be affirmed on appeal, given the Federal Court’s decision in Anas Construction and the doctrine of stare decicis.

The question then arises as to whether CIPAA adjudication has turned into a rigid tool departing from the ‘pay now, argue later’, ‘quick and dirty’, ‘rough justice’ and interim finality bedrock to assist with the cash flow issues in the construction industry as the policy makers had envisaged, which has been recognised by the Courts over the years.

Perhaps it would be of assistance if one were to also ascertain if an adjudication decision remains easily enforceable. Under CIPAA, in order to enforce an adjudication decision, one may do so by applying to the High Court to register and enforce the adjudication decision as a judgment of the High Court.

Since the Court of Appeal’s decision in Likas Bay Precinct Sdn Bhd v Bina Puri Sdn Bhd [2019] 3 MLJ 244, which had allowed a winding up petition based on an adjudication decision even though the adjudication decision had not been registered as a judgment of the High Court, CIPAA adjudication had been highly utilised as being an effective tool.

In Likas Bay Precinct, the Court of Appeal held that it was not a mandatory requirement that there must be a judgment entered in favour of the respondent for the amount that was claimed and pursued against the appellant; that a creditor who was not paid had a right to file a petition to wind up the debtor company; that the adjudication decision had found an amount to be due and owing to the respondent from the appellant; that as there was no application by the appellant to set aside the adjudication decision, an adjudication decision was good and proper as a basis upon which a winding up petition may be filed for the amount found to be due and payable in the adjudication decision.

Before one undertakes the commencement of winding up proceedings based on an adjudication decision, it is worthwhile to bear in mind the following guidelines from the recent Court of Appeal’s decision in VKPT Sdn Bhd v Lic Infra Sdn Bhd [2026] MLJU 2847:-

  1. A registered adjudication decision resulting in a judgment debt is, subject to appeal or stay, indisputable. The party against whom judgment is entered cannot, absent a cross-claim or set-off, deny liability for the judgment debt in collateral proceedings.
  2. Where the adjudication decision has not been registered under section 28 of CIPAA, the debt retains its character as an adjudicated, but not judicially determined, debt. It has persuasive weight as evidence that the sum is owed but it does not carry the conclusive force of a judgment. In these circumstances, the debtor company is entitled to challenge the winding up petition by demonstrating that the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds.
  3. A pending application to set aside or stay the adjudication decision under sections 15 and 16 CIPAA does not by itself affect this analysis. The relevant question is the legal character of the debt, not the procedural steps taken to challenge it.
  4. A winding up petition subject to an arbitration clause should only be stayed where the debt was genuinely disputed on substantial grounds (the Sian test).
  5. The Sian test is perfectly calibrated to the policy objective of CIPAA in that insubstantial challenges should not be permitted to delay enforcement.
  6. However CIPAA’s ‘pay now, argue later’ philosophy does not support the elevation of an unregistered adjudication decision to the status of an unimpeachable judgment. Such elevation requires the additional step of a section 28 registration.
  7. Once an adjudication decision has been registered under section 28 as a judgment, the debt takes on the conclusive character of a court judgment and the debtor company cannot simply re-open the underlying dispute to resist the winding up petition.
  8. The avenue of challenge that remains available is the demonstration of a cross-claim or set-off that is bona fide on substantial grounds and that equals or exceeds the judgment.
  9. It is not sufficient for a company facing a winding up petition to merely aver  by affidavit the existence of a meritorious counterclaim and exhibit for proof the statement of defence and counterclaim, which is not evidence. Evidence is required.
  10. The company must set out in the affidavit the facts on which the counterclaim is based, giving the necessary details so as to lend earnestness and weight to their claim and so that the petitioner will have a fair opportunity to present his side of the story by affidavit and the court, by considering the affidavits, will be able to assess, without actually deciding it, whether the claim has weight or raises a serious issue.
  11. A section 16 stay application operates within the CIPAA regime to suspend the binding force of the adjudication decision as an enforcement instrument.
  12. It does not however in itself resolve the question of whether the underlying debt is genuinely disputed; that remains a question for the winding-up court, to be determined by the Sian test.

This material is for general information only and is not intended to provide legal advice. If you have any queries regarding construction contracts, please feel free to contact Janet Chai Pei Ying at janetchai@chooi.com.my.